Final Research Paper
Research Proposal
: What are the consequences of stigmatizing mental health concerns and why do they exist?
Diana araujo
Department of English, CUNY John Jay College of Criminal Justice
101 31: College Composition I: Exploration and Authorship An Inquiry-Based Writing
12/21/2021
Professor N. Matyakubova
How mental health disorders are seen in various cultures and communities And why that is? Including whether or not many well-known treatments and educational systems have a beneficial or bad impact? how so? Unfortunately in many households, mental health issues are rarely addressed, and when they are where it’s severely looked down upon. It's perceived and labeled as insane, lazy, or just for the weak-minded. Many people have this experience and many have trouble reaching out for help because of this. Why is it that social norms and social class determine if a person is “normal” vs “different” When it comes to mental health for over decades society seems to never truly accept and understand it. For many years mental health issues have been stigmatized and demonetized, people have been looked at as crazy, insane, emotional, and every other name in the book. society has locked people in institutions or pretended it doesn’t exist. For the number of people in this world that suffer from some type of mental health disorder, one would think that there would be better access to treatments or assistance and help that would be needed. This research will display the effects of labeling and stigmatizing.
The stigmatizing of mental health disorders has been present for a long time. Individuals suffering from mental health disorders were historically considered as "demon-possessed," further reducing their standing in society's eyes. And subjecting them to severe cruelty by both society and the system. In today's environment, social media and news sources play a large role in stigmatizing mental health concerns and the effects it has on students as well as their desire to seek counseling treatment as a result of it. “Due to societal stigmatic views, individuals who needed or wanted to utilize mental health services found it difficult to avoid the label of "mentally ill". Consequently, students may then perceive being the object of negative views and ostracizing effect from society and feel their achievements were diminished socially or academically. If students were seen as deviating from the normal population by seeking counseling, they could experience undue stigma” Holland,(2016) Demonstrating how the more stigmas there exist, the fewer kids desire to seek help and therapy since they don't want to be classified or judged a particular way as a result of it. It is critical that we as a culture correct this and allow our pupils to get treatment if they need it by making the theme Comfortable and ending society's ongoing stigmatization of mental health concerns.
For many years mental illness has been attributed to familial tensions, the ability to receive heavenly messages, the involvement of supernatural powers or events, or something predestined. Culture has a tremendous impact on how society perceives our health, and different cultures view this as a positive or negative factor. “Stigmatizing attitudes also vary across cultures. People with mental illnesses are perceived as more dangerous and less competent of managing their own affairs in varying degrees across cultures. In some Asian cultures, stigma is so extreme that mental illness is thought to reflect poorly on family lineage and thereby diminishes marriage and economic prospects for other family members as well” Putul( 2018) In many locations, culture and different groups play an active part in how mental illness is addressed. It is apparent that stigmatizing mental health issues has a significant influence on the individual and others around them in various societies and cultures. The history of mental health issues in the United States is a very long and dark one, one that
resulted in many deaths, and unfair treatments. Over the years now that judgment and stigma still stick around and impacts those who experience that in their daily life as community one of the best things that we can do is influence positivity and learn from our past mistakes in order to better our future and the people in it
One article brings the idea that In inpatient psychiatric wards Violence has been a common problem, endangering the safety and well-being of mental patients. Some sources of negative environmental and interpersonal stimulation enhance the aggressive behavior of patients with psychotic illnesses on the wards. In today's world, psychiatric care is no longer limited to hospital settings; instead, more patients with serious mental diseases are being treated in community-based settings. “nevertheless, patients' safety and wellbeing are threatened by violence from patients on inpatient psychiatric wards [52, 53]. Nijman and his associates claimed that the hospital's environment inescapably introduces stressors on the patient. The violent behavior by patients with psychotic disorders on the wards is exacerbated by some negative forms of environmental and interpersonal stimulation such as the disorganization of a crowded psychiatric ward, noise [22], the lack of interesting activities, and/or problematic communication with staff members” Chows, & Priebe, (2013, June 18). Institutions can have both a negative and beneficial impact on people, and there are numerous tales that demonstrate both are valid in this case. And the absence of organization, which leads to undesirable behaviors among patients as well as between patients and psychiatric staff members. This article emphasizes the idea that one of the key issues is overpopulation and a lack of activities for the patient. Overall, it demonstrates the basic importance of finance. If society cared more about its citizens, there would be far more exposure and financing for therapies and institutions.
One book, Social Perspectives in Mental Health: Developing Social Models to Understand and Work with Mental Distress. Describes the significance of internal power and what it means in the context of mental health problems, in addition to the effects that society and the stigmatization of it might cause. It described how power is not a 'thing,' but a social interaction between people that can open or close doors for individuals. Feeling more in charge of one's life and being open to getting assistance may help lead to a more positive and less self-destructive path as well as maintaining a healthy relationship with others. It stated that “The process of recovery from mental distress also connects with issues of power. Recovery may involve reclaiming a place in social, cultural, family, or economic systems from which one has been excluded (‘Warner, 1994’;)... This may involve accessing, or being denied access to, particular forms of social relationships and specific ‘allocative and authoritative resources’ (‘Giddens, 1994’)... being seen as ‘different’ from dominant cultural, social or economic norms may often turn out to be disadvantageous or injurious to one’s well-being.” Tew. (2005).
Shows the results of how a concept of power can be reclaimed. But even then social norms can have a great impact on experiences. It’s the fact that a certain type of thinking can deny thousands of people resources. It's important to start changing that and find ways to get internal power.
Societies heavenly effects power shift due to Stigmatization and judgment that many receive and witness. One study was conducted comparing how specific questions pertained to people with repeating 12-month mental health disorders against those who do not have recurring 12-month disorders. Some of the results and conclusions include how the recurring-disorder group had a more negative affect, severe symptoms, and mental health crash days, treatment experience, understanding of their diagnosis, and greater service usage experience than the no-disorder group. Another noteworthy aspect of the data that was highlighted was the difference and similarity on stigma corners, as well as the potential shame that may emerge from it. “Unexpectedly, the two groups do not differ on stigma concerns (possible embarrassment)... The fact that formal labeling was associated with harm in both the recurrent-disorder and no-disorder groups while the well-being effects of treatment differed noticeably between the two groups underscores again the importance of keeping labeling and treatment measures distinct from one another” Thoits. (2021)
It explains how formal labeling caused harm to both groups. Furthermore, the beneficial outcomes of treatment differed across the two groups. Stressing the need of keeping labeling and treatment measures distinct. There's no doubt that there are reasonable differences between the groups. But one thing that was very interesting was that both of them had witnessed the effects of stigmatizing and labeling on those who have a history of mental health disorders. As well as the fear of that stigma and concerns. Demonstrating how the effects of society's stigmas and unwillingness to change and learn are feared by many, whether personally affected or not.
In an interview with Nancy Pace therapist of Hudson Guild was asked 6 questions regarding her personal opinion on mental health issues and the act of stigmas.
What is your opinion on institutionalization?
“Using the Social Work Code of Ethics as a guide, I believe institutionalization serves a purpose of protecting someone from themselves and others when they are incapable of self-determination; However, I believe institutions propagate injustices and unfairly target marginalized communities and they do not always respect patient's inherent dignity and worth as a person.”
What is the general effect that institutions can bring both negative and positive?
“Institutions are well-resourced which provides people who have been suffering alone with mental illness the opportunity to receive the level of care they need. On the other hand, being institutionalized means arresting your freedoms and obligations to one's career and relationships that can cause further damage to the individual's life.”
In your opinion what’s the best method of coping and minimizing the effects of mental health issues
“In managing mental health issues, it is vital to have the support of friends, loved ones and peers/colleagues. Our society's stigma of mental health challenges make it so many people suffer alone and therefore aren't connected to the appropriate care and resources they need. Therefore, on the individual level, people need to have a set of coping skills that help them manage difficult moments, but on the mezzo- and macro-levels, we must all work together to normalize mental health issues so individuals have an easier time acquiring said skills with a mental health professional. The two efforts work hand-in-hand.”
How have society’s sigmas affected those who have mental health issues
“As mentioned above, the stigma against mental health affects everyone. For example, even if I don't have mental health challenges, there are certainly people I care about who face depression and anxiety who are ashamed of recognizing their own suffering and taking actions to get connected to therapeutic resources. This lack of recognition and action forces those around them to deal with the fallout of untreated poor mental health.”
Do you think that the educational system has a positive or negative impact? why/why not?
“I think this depends on a school-by-school basis. Better resourced schools, therefore schools with higher property taxes, have the means to provide extensive mental health education, prevention and treatment. In this way, students at those schools feel more supported and aware of the signs and symptoms of declining mental health. In less resourced schools, students likely don't experience the same level of intervention.”
In what ways can we as a society better improve the stigmas behind it?
“I think we all need to work together to raise awareness of the signs and symptoms of mental health and correct misinformation. I believe we can do this by speaking openly about our emotions and supporting others in doing the same.”
Dr. Jeffrey Lieberman, Professor and Chair of Psychiatry at Columbia University and previous President of the American Psychiatric Association, believes that removing the stigma associated with mental health would result in improved treatment for millions of people. In this Ted Talk video, he discusses the stigmas associated with mental health disorders, and how, according to the World Health Organization, 20% of the world's population suffers from some form of mental health illness at some point in their lives, or one in every five individuals. He claimed that statistically, everyone should know at least one person who suffers from some form of mental health issue, yet many do not, which means three things. 1) There is a significant lack of understanding about it, 2) many people are ashamed and/or hesitant to confess it, and 3) mental illness is heavily stigmatized.
He then offers a demonstration of how study, public knowledge, and information may lead to treatments, perhaps leading to a reduction in the stigma associated with it. He then goes on to say. “So, we Don't have treatments for every disorder, I'm not all patients respond well. But make no mistake there is indisputably a world of difference Between modern mental health care today And what existed for all human history Prior to the latter part of the 20th century. So I find it particularly ironic That well people suffered from mental disorders Throughout human history because of the fact we had no knowledge and limited or no effective treatments, In the 21st century we do have treatments The biggest barriers are lack of awareness Lack of access to care and stigma.” Lieberman (He then goes on to say that if there was no stigma, we would be able to learn how to launch a public health initiative against mental illness, as we have done effectively with infectious illnesses, lead, and heart disease. He explained that we would begin with two distinct tactics, the first of which includes early detection and intervention. The second option would be to provide comprehensive community-based treatment to people who are already in severe stages of the condition. This video is an essential illustration of how stigma influences not just the advancement of particular research and knowledge in society, but also how we may directly affect persons suffering from mental diseases. Because of the stigma attached to it, the effective research and treatments could help millions of people. further showing that Society should do better. There is so much promise in what we can do as a community to tackle this issue, but not with the cement setback. If everyone knows at least one person who suffers from some form of mental health condition, why do so many people choose to utterly disregard it and stigmatize it to the point that many people are unable to receive the necessary treatment and attention that they deserve?
Finally, the stigmatization of mental health disorders has a negative impact on people and the difficulties they face. As a society, we must work together to find solutions to the tremendous stigmas and harshness that many people have faced and endured. Society should not perceive those who are different as inferior and something to be ashamed of, and the fact that it has been a continuing issue for many decades and has yet to be handled is a concern. Something that stood out throughout this research was the fact that many of the books, videos, and articles mentioned almost the same thing, which was that better understanding and compassion can go a long way and that the more people who are interested, the better the community can help and support each other.
References
Holland, D. (2016). COLLEGE STUDENT STRESS AND MENTAL HEALTH: EXAMINATION OF STIGMATIC VIEWS ON MENTAL HEALTH COUNSELING. Michigan Sociological Review, 30, 16–43. http://www.jstor.org/stable/43940346
Putul, M., Kahua, T. D., Choudhury, M. K., & Shobhana, M. (2018). The Influence of Culture and Society on Mental Health. Medico-Legal Update, 18(2), 198–201. https://doi-org.ez.lib.jjay.cuny.edu/10.5958/0974-1283.2018.00156.1
TEDxTalks. (2016). Imagine There Was No Stigma to Mental Illness. Dr. Jeffrey Lieberman. Retrieved November 4, 2021, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WrbTbB9tTtA.
Chow, W. s, & Priebe, S. (2013, June 18). Understanding psychiatric institutionalization: A conceptual review. BMC Psychiatry. Retrieved November 6, 2021, from https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/1471-244X-13-169#citeas.
Thoits. (2021). Disentangling Mental Illness Labeling Effects from Treatment Effects on Well-Being. Society and Mental Health, 11(3), 183–200. https://doi.org/10.1177/2156869320949598
Tew. (2005). Social perspectives in mental health developing social models to understand and work with mental distress (1st American pbk. ed.). Jessica Kingsley.
Society and mental health. (2011). Sage Publications on behalf of American Sociological
Comments
Post a Comment